Annexure C

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON INSURANCE BUSINESSES

     

1. 

 

Accounting policies

 
   These accounting policies form part of the group accounting policies in note 1 to the group annual financial statements. 
  

Insurance and investment contracts

 
  

Long-term insurance operations

 
   The long-term insurance operations issue contracts that transfer insurance risk or financial risk or both. Insurance contracts are those contracts that transfer significant insurance risk. Such contracts may also transfer financial risk. Investment contracts are those contracts that transfer financial risk with no significant insurance risk.

Insurance contracts are classified into individual credit life contracts, individual life contracts, group funeral, group life and group credit life contracts.

All policyholder contracts that transfer significant insurance risk are classified as insurance contracts. These contracts are valued in terms of the Financial Soundness Valuation (FSV) basis contained in PGN 104 issued by the Actuarial Society of South Africa.

The statutory actuary calculates the liabilities under long-term insurance contracts and investment contracts annually at the balance sheet date in accordance with prevailing legislation, Generally Accepted Actuarial Standards in South Africa and International Financial Reporting Standards as appropriate. The transfers to or from insurance liabilities in the income statement represent the increase or decrease in contract liabilities, including all necessary provisions and reserves.

The Financial Soundness Valuation basis requires at each balance sheet date that liability adequacy tests are performed to ensure the adequacy of the contract liabilities. The liabilities for investment contracts are set equal to the accumulated fair value of the underlying assets. Any deficiency is immediately charged to profit and loss and a provision is raised for losses from the liability adequacy tests.

Policyholder contracts that do not transfer significant insurance risk are classified as investment contracts. Investment contracts are initially and thereafter recognised at fair value, with changes in fair value being accounted for in the income statement. The premiums and benefit payments relating to these investment contracts have been excluded from the income statement and accounted for directly as movements in the liability.

Once a contract has been classified as an insurance contract, it remains an insurance contract for the remainder of its lifetime, even if the insurance risk reduces significantly during this period, unless all rights and obligations are extinguished or expire. Investment contracts can however be reclassified as insurance contracts after inception, if insurance risk becomes significant.

Short-term insurance operations

Contracts under which the short-term insurance operations accept significant insurance risk from another party (the policyholder) by agreeing to compensate the policyholder or other beneficiary if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the policyholder, or other beneficiary, are classified as insurance contracts. Insurance risk is risk other than financial risk, transferred from the holder of the contract to the issuer. Financial risk is the risk of a possible future change in one or more of a specified interest rate, security price, commodity price, foreign exchange rate, index of prices or rates, a credit rating or credit index or other variables. Insurance contracts may also transfer some financial risk.

Reinsurance of long-term and short-term insurance operations

Contracts entered into with reinsurers by the long-term and short-term operations, under which the group is compensated for losses on one or more contracts, and which meet the classification requirements for insurance contracts, are classified as reinsurance contracts held.

The benefits to which the long-term and short-term operations are entitled under their reinsurance contracts held are recognised as reinsurance assets, consisting of short-term and long-term balances due from reinsurers that are dependent on the expected claims and benefits. Reinsurance liabilities are primarily premiums payable and are recognised as an expense when due. Reinsurance assets are assessed for impairment on an annual basis, reducing the carrying amount of the reinsurance asset to its recoverable amount through the income statement.

Insurance results

Long-term insurance operations

Profits or losses are determined in accordance with the guidance note on Financial Soundness Valuations (PGN 104) and International Financial Reporting Standards. The underlying philosophy of the Financial Soundness Valuation is to recognise profits prudently over the term of each insurance contract. In the valuation of liabilities, provision is made for:

  • The best estimate of future experience;
  • Compulsory margins prescribed in the Long-term Insurance Act, 1998; and
  • Discretionary margins determined to release profits to shareholders consistent with policy design and company policy.

Short-term insurance operations

The underwriting results are determined after making provisions for unearned premiums, outstanding claims, incurred but not reported claims, unexpired risk provision and such additional provisions as are considered necessary. The methods used to determine these provisions are as follows:

Unearned premiums

Premiums are earned from the date the risk attaches, over the indemnity period, based on the pattern of the risk underwritten. Unearned premiums, which represent the proportion of premiums written in the current year which relate to risks that have not expired by the end of the financial year, are calculated on the 365th basis for even risk business and other bases that best represent the unearned risk profile for uneven risk business.

Claims

Claims incurred consist of claims and claims handling expenses paid during the financial year together with the movement in the provision for outstanding claims. Claims outstanding comprise provisions for the estimate of the ultimate cost of settling all claims incurred but unpaid at the balance sheet date whether reported or not, and an appropriate risk margin. Related anticipated reinsurance recoveries are disclosed separately as assets. These estimated reinsurance and other recoveries are assessed in a manner similar to the assessment of claims outstanding.

Whilst the directors consider that the gross provisions for claims and the related reinsurance recoveries are fairly stated on the basis of the information currently available to them, the ultimate liability will vary as a result of subsequent information and events and may result in significant adjustments to the amounts provided. Adjustments to the amounts of claims provisions established in prior years are reflected in the financial statements for the period in which the adjustments are made, and disclosed separately if material. The methods used to value these provisions, and the estimates made, are reviewed regularly.

IBNR

These are calculated on both a best estimate and 75th percentile trend to be consistent with the proposed Financial Condition Reporting requirements.

Unexpired risk provision

Provision is made for unexpired risks arising to the extent that the expected value of claims and claims handling expenses attributable to the unexpired periods of contracts in force at the balance sheet date exceeds the unearned premiums provision in relation to such contracts after the deduction of any deferred acquisition costs.

Deferred acquisition costs

The costs of acquiring new and renewal insurance business that is commission and other acquisition costs, primarily related to the products of that business, are deferred. Deferred acquisition costs are amortised on a pro-rata basis over the contract term. Similarly, any reinsurance commissions received are deferred and recognised as income over the term of the reinsurance contract.

Revenue recognition

Long-term insurance operations

Premiums and annuity considerations on insurance contracts are recognised when due in terms of the contract, other than group schemes. Premiums receivable in respect of group schemes are recognised when there is reasonable assurance of collection in terms of the policy contract. Premium income on insurance contracts is shown gross of reinsurance. Premiums are shown before deduction of commission. Premium income received in advance is included in Trade and other payables. Amounts received under investment contracts, such as premiums, are recorded as deposits to investment contract liabilities.

Short-term insurance operations

Gross written premiums comprise the premiums on insurance contracts entered into during the year, irrespective of whether they relate in whole or in part to a later accounting period. Premiums are disclosed gross of commission to intermediaries and exclude Value Added Tax. Premiums written include adjustments to premiums written in the prior accounting periods and estimates for pipeline premiums (premiums written relating to current accounting period but not reported by the balance sheet date). The earned portion of the premium received is released from the unearned premium provision. Premiums are earned from the date of attachment of risk, over the indemnity period, based on the pattern of risks underwritten.

Contingency reserve

Short-term insurance operations

The statutory contingency reserve is created in accordance with the provisions of the Short-term Insurance Act, 1998, of South Africa.

Withdrawals from this reserve may only be made with the consent of the Registrar of Short-term Insurance. The annual adjustment to the reserve account for premium increases or decreases during the year is reflected as an appropriation to or from distributable reserves.

Cell captives

The group operates cell captives on behalf of entities that wish to participate in the insurance result of a particular category of insured risk. Preference shares are issued to those participants giving them the right to share in profits on an agreed basis. To reflect the substance of the transaction it is consolidated and the participants share of profits is treated as a minority interest.

 
      2009  2008 
      Rm  Rm 

2.

 

Other investments and loans

 
     
   (note 11 to the group annual financial statements)      
           
2.1  Financial assets held at fair value       
   Balance at beginning of year  1 635  1 844 
   Additions  1 123  1 895 
   Disposals  (1 787) (2 121)
   Fair value adjustment  (138) 17 
   Balance at end of year  833  1 635 
           
2.2  Reconciliation to group annual financial statements       
   Financial assets at fair value – insurance businesses  833  1 635 
   Financial assets at fair value – other operations  8  309 
      841  1 944 

3.

 

Insurance assets and liabilities

 
     
           
3.1  Liabilities under insurance contracts       
   Short-term operations       
   Outstanding claims, including claims incurred but not reported       
   – Balance at beginning of year  706  680 
   – Claims settled in the year  (1 328) (1 263)
   – Increase in liabilities  1 247  1 289 
   Balance at end of year  625  706 
   Outstanding claims  465  563 
   Incurred but not reported  160  143 
   Balance at end of year  625  706 
   This amount is reflected in trade and other payables       
           
3.2  Unearned premium provision       
   Balance at beginning of year  742  792 
   Premiums written during the year  2 149  1 953 
   Premiums earned during the year  (2 228) (2 003)
   Balance at end of year  663  742 
           
3.3  Long-term operations       
   Balance at beginning of year  722  891 
   Transfer to income statement  (109) (160)
   Arising from translation of foreign liabilities  (3) (9)
   Balance at end of year  610  722 
  

Process used to decide on long-term insurance assumptions

The business was divided up into homogeneous groupings and then each grouping was analysed. Best estimate assumptions were then derived based on these experience investigations. Where data was limited, market statistics were used. Recent trends evident in the data were allowed for.

The value of insurance liabilities is based on best estimate assumptions of future experience plus compulsory margins as required in terms of PGN 104, plus additional discretionary margins determined by the statutory actuary.

 
        The compulsory margins are summarised as follows: 
   Assumption  Compulsory margin 
   Investment earnings  0,25% increase or decrease in investment earnings rate depending on which gives the higher liability 
           
   Expense inflation  10% loading i.e. 1,1 times the expense inflation assumption used 
   Mortality  Assumption was increased by 7,5% i.e. 1,075 times the relevant mortality rate 
   Morbidity  Assumption was increased by 10% i.e. 1,1 times the relevant mortality rate. For dread disease the margin is 15% 
   Retrenchment  Assumption was increased by 20% i.e. 1,2 times the relevant retrenchment rate 
   Lapses  25% increase or decrease in lapse rates depending on which gives the higher liability i.e. multiply by 1,25 or 0,75 
   Surrenders  10% increase or decrease in surrender rates depending on which gives the higher liability i.e. multiply by 1,1 or 0,9 
   Expenses  10% loading i.e. 1,1 times the expense assumption used 
           
   In addition to the above compulsory margins the following additional discretionary margins were incorporated: 
   Retrenchment  An additional 30% margin was added 
   Expenses  Individual Life has an additional 10% discretionary margin 
   Extended lives mortality  An additional 7,5% margin was added 
   All other decrements  For credit life an additional 10% margin was added 
           
   Negative reserves were recognised in full. 
           
   The specific process of deriving the best estimate assumptions relating to future mortality, morbidity, medical, withdrawals, investment returns, maintenance expenses, expense inflation and tax are described below: 
  

a)

 

Mortality

 
      Adjusted standard assured lives and annuity tables were used to reflect the group’s recent claims experience. The adjustments are based on annual mortality investigations conducted into the different classes of business and also allow for the expected increase in AIDS related claims. The allowance for AIDS is based on the relevant actuarial guidance notes as provided by the Actuarial Society of South Africa (ASSA). 
  

b)

 

Morbidity

 
      Disability and dread disease rates are based on standard morbidity tables and where appropriate, adjusted to reflect the group’s recent claims experience. Adjustments made are based on investigations conducted once a year.  
  

c)

 

Medical and retrenchment

 
      The incidence of medical and retrenchment claims is derived from the risk premium rates determined from annual investigations. The incidence rates are reviewed on an annual basis, based on claims experience. The adjusted rates are intended to reflect future expected experience.  
  

d)

 

Withdrawal

 
      The withdrawal assumptions are based on the most recent withdrawal investigations taking into account past as well as expected future trends. The withdrawal investigation is performed each year and incorporates ten months’ experience. The withdrawal rates are analysed by class and policy duration. These withdrawal rates vary by duration, distribution channel, product type and company. Typically the rates are higher at early durations. 
  

e)

 

Investment returns

 
      Separate investment returns were derived for the annuity and non-annuity business. Furthermore, for the non-annuity business, separate interest rates were determined for Individual Life and Credit Life classes of business. The returns were based on the current bond yields of appropriate term and long-term differentials between bonds, cash and equities. The assumptions were based on the long-term rates and notional matched portfolio of assets. Allowance was made for mismatches. 
        
      The long-term investment returns (before compulsory margins) are as follows: 
      Credit life single premium business: 6,97% (2008: 10,9%)
      Credit life regular premium business: 8,37% (2008: 10,9%)
      Individual life: 8,65% (2008: 10,9%)
      Annuity business: 9,16% (2008: 10,5%)
  

f)

 

Renewal expenses and inflation

 
      A detailed expense investigation was undertaken and the expenses were split by line of business and between new business and maintenance expenses. 
        
      The maintenance expenses were adjusted for expected inflation in the future and spread over the anticipated volumes of business over the next year to derive a per policy expense for each class. The expenses allocated to new business are expected to be covered by future new business written.  
  

g)

 

Tax

 
      The interest assumptions are net of any tax payable by the group. Note that currently the group is in an excess expense tax position in its policyholder funds and no tax is payable on investment income. Interest rates are net of any capital gains tax. 
     

Change in assumptions

The following changes were made to the Published Reporting valuation basis. All assumptions include compulsory margins.

For South Africa, the economic assumptions were reviewed to reflect the current economic environment, as follows:

  • The discount rate for credit life business was reduced from 10,65% to 8,62%. The discount rate for individual life and mortgage business was reduced from 10,65% to 8,40%. The discount rate for the disability annuitant business was reduced from 10,25% to 8,91%.
  • The loan interest rate for credit life and mortgage business was reduced from 17,75% to 13,75% per annum.
  • Expense inflation for all business was reduced from 9,46% to 6,99%.
  • The assumed rate of pension increases for the disability annuity business was reduced from 8,78% to 6,51% per annum.

As a result of these economic changes, the actuarial liabilities reduced by R15,8 million.

The non-economic assumptions were also reviewed as follows:

  • The death, permanent disability, temporary disability, retrenchment and AIDS assumptions were adjusted to reflect the recent claims experience. The combined effect resulted in a R14,8 million release in actuarial liabilities.
  • Per policy expenses were amended to reflect the current and expected future experience. This resulted in a release in actuarial liabilities of R15,8 million.
  • The withdrawal assumptions were adjusted to reflect the recent lapse experience. This resulted in a release in actuarial liabilities of R6,6 million.

As a result of these non-economic changes, the actuarial liabilities reduced by R37,2 million.

The overall impact of all the above changes was a reduction in the actuarial liabilities of R53 million.

Regarding Botswana, the value of liabilities as at 30 June 2009 reduced by P2,7 million as a result of changes to valuation assumptions.

The main assumption changes causing this release were as follows:

  • The renewal expense assumptions were amended in the light of the most recent expense investigation. This resulted in a release of P2,1 million.
  • The economic assumptions were amended to reflect the current economic environment. This resulted in a strain of P0,5 million.
  • The withdrawal assumptions were amended to reflect the recent withdrawal experience. This resulted in a weakening of P0,2 million.
  • The permanent disability, dread disease, temporary disability and mortality (including AIDS) assumptions were adjusted to reflect the recent claims experience. This resulted in a release of P0,9 million.
 
  

Sensitivity analysis

 
   The following table presents the sensitivity of the value of insurance liabilities disclosed in this note to movements in the assumptions used in the estimation of insurance liabilities. 
              
        Change in  Change in 
        liability  liability 
        2009  2008 
   Variable   Change in variable  Rm  Rm 
   Worsening of mortality   10% worse claims  32,1  38,4 
   Lowering of investment returns   15% lower returns  12,8  37,6 
   Worsening of base renewal expense level   10% higher expenses  17,5  14,9 
   Worsening of expense inflation   10% higher expenses  5,2 
   Worsening of lapse rate   25% higher withdrawals  6,5  1,2 
              
   The 2009 investment sensitivity resulted in a smaller impact compared with last year due to the run off of single premium business as well as the change in direction of the interest rate margin on the published basis for the monthly premium Credit Life business. 
     
   The above analysis is based on a change in an assumption while holding all other assumptions constant. In practice, this is unlikely to occur, and the changes in some assumptions may be correlated – e.g. change in interest rate and change in market values. 
     
         2009  2008 
         Rm  Rm 
3.4  Financial liabilities under investment contracts – long-term operations          
   Balance at beginning of year     71  39 
   Deposits     16  35 
   Payments     (4) (3)
   Balance at end of year     83  71 
              
3.5  Reconciliation to group annual financial statements          
   Insurance and investment contracts          
   (note 23 to the group annual financial statements)         
   Short-term operations – unearned premium provisions (See 3.2)    663  742 
   Long-term operations: Liabilities under insurance contracts (See 3.3)    610  722 
   Long-term operations: Liabilities under investment contracts (See 3.4)    83  71 
         1 356  1 535 
              
3.6  Reinsurers’ share of liabilities under insurance contracts          
   (note 12 to the group annual financial statements)         
   Balance at beginning of year     313  542 
   Movement in reinsurer’s share of insurance liabilities     (110) (229)
   Balance at end of year     203  313 
              
3.7  Insurance claims provisions          
   (note 25 to the group annual financial statements)         
   Short-term operations – IBNR (See 3.1)    160  143 
   Long-term and other operations – outstanding claims provisions     71  82 
         231  225 

4.

 

Revenue

 
        
   (note 27 to the group annual financial statements)         
              
   Premium income          
   Long-term operations          
   Individual premium income          
   – Singe premiums     256  218 
   – Reinsurance     (7) (3)
   Net premium income     249  215 
   – Recurring premiums     260  138 
   – Reinsurance     (19) (4)
   Net premium income     241  134 
   Group life premium income          
   – Recurring premiums     143  169 
   – Reinsurance     (35) (34)
   Net premium income     108  135 
   Net premium income from long-term operations     598  484 
   Short-term and reinsurance operations          
   Gross premiums written     2 008  1 853 
   Outward reinsurance premiums/retrocession premiums     (338) (326)
   Net premium income from short-term and reinsurance operations     1 670  1 527 
   Total net premium income     2 268  2 011 
   Total external gross premium income     2 667  2 378 

5.

 

Management of insurance-specific risks

 
  

Insurance risk

 
  

Long-term insurance operations

Insurance risk is the risk that future claims and expenses will exceed the premiums received to take on this risk.
It occurs due to the uncertainty of the timing and amount of future cash flows arising under insurance contracts. This could also occur because of the frequency or severity of claims and benefits being greater than estimated. Insurance events are random and the actual number and amount of claims and benefits will vary from year to year from the estimate using statistical techniques.

The long-term insurance operations use appropriate base tables of standard mortality according to the type of contract being written and the territory in which the insured person resides. An investigation into the actual experience of the group over the last three years is carried out, and statistical methods are used to adjust the crude mortality rates to produce a best estimate of expected mortality for the future. Termination statistics to investigate the deviation of actual termination experience against assumptions are used. Statistical methods are used to determine appropriate termination rates. An allowance is then made for any trends in the data to arrive at the best estimate of future termination rates.

Short-term operations

The group underwrites risks that natural persons, corporates or other entities wish to transfer to an insurer. Such risks may relate to property, accident, personal accident, motor, engineering, marine, liability and aviation. As such the operation is exposed to uncertainty surrounding the timing, frequency and severity of claims under insurance contracts. The principal risk is that the frequency and/or severity of claims are greater than expected. Insurance events are by their nature random and the actual size and number of events in any one year may vary from those estimated and experienced in prior periods.

The group underwrites primarily short-tailed risks, that is, insurance under which claims are typically settled within one year of the occurrence of the events giving rise to the claims. Risks that are long-tailed in nature represent an insignificant portion of the group’s insurance portfolio. Therefore the group’s exposure at any time to insurance contracts issued more than one year before is limited.

Capital adequacy and solvency risk

Long-term operations

The capital adequacy requirement is determined according to generally accepted actuarial principles in terms of the guidelines issued by the Actuarial Society of South Africa. It is an estimate of the minimum capital that will be required to meet fairly substantial deviations from the main assumptions affecting the group’s business. At 30 June 2009 the capital adequacy requirement is R72 million and the ratio of excess assets to capital adequacy requirements is 3,9 (2008: R120 million, capital adequacy ratio 2,9).

Short-term operations

The group submits quarterly and annual returns to the Financial Services Board that show the solvency position of its insurance operations. The group is required to maintain, at all times, a statutory surplus asset ratio and free assets after spreading limitations as defined in the Short-term Insurance Act, 1998 (the Act). The returns submitted by the company to the regulator showed that the company met the minimum capital requirements at the year-end date.

Underwriting risk

Long-term insurance operations

The Statutory Actuary reports annually on the actuarial soundness of the premium rates in use and the profitability of the business taking into consideration the reasonable benefit expectation of policyholders. All new rate tables are approved and authorised by the Statutory Actuary prior to being issued. Annual investigations into mortality and morbidity experience are conducted. All applications for risk cover in excess of specified limits are reviewed by experienced underwriters and evaluated against established standards. All risk-related liabilities in excess of specified monetary or impairment limits are reinsured.

Short-term insurance operations

The operation limits its exposure to insurance risk through setting a clearly defined underwriting strategy and limits, adopting appropriate risk assessment techniques and the reinsurance of risks that exceed its risk appetite. The underwriting strategy ensures diversification of insurance risk in terms of type and amount of risk covered, geographical location and type of industry covered. The strategy also aims to develop a sufficiently large population of risks to reduce the variability of the expected outcome. Ongoing review and analysis of underwriting information enables the group to monitor its risks and take timely corrective action.

Regulatory risks

Continuous legislation changes in the long-term and short-term environment may impact severely on the operational and financial structures within these businesses. The group has sufficient resources to address the impact of legislation timeously and efficiently.

During the development stage of any new product, rights and obligations of all parties are clearly defined in the contracts and documentation.

Financial risk

Long-term insurance operations

The group is exposed to financial risk through its financial assets, financial liabilities, reinsurance assets and insurance liabilities. In particular, the key financial risk is that the proceeds from its financial assets are not sufficient to fund the obligations arising from its insurance and investment contracts. Components of this financial risk are interest rate risk, equity price risk, currency risk and credit risk. An investment committee sets policies and receives monthly and quarterly reports on compliance with investment policies.

The long-term insurance operations manage these positions within an asset liability management (ALM) framework that has been developed to achieve long-term investment returns in excess of its obligations under insurance and investment contracts. The principal technique of the ALM framework is to match assets to the liabilities arising from insurance and investment contracts by reference to the type of benefits payable to policyholders.

Short-term insurance operations

The short-term operations are exposed to daily calls on its available cash resources from claims arising. Liabilities are matched by appropriate assets and the operations have significant liquid resources to cover its obligations.

Catastrophic risk

Short-term insurance operations

The operation sets out the total aggregate exposure that it is prepared to accept in certain territories to a range of events such as natural catastrophes. The aggregate position is reviewed annually. The group uses a number of modelling tools to monitor aggregation and to simulate catastrophe losses in order to measure the effectiveness of the reinsurance programmes and the net exposure of the operations.

Credit risk

Fair values of financial assets may be affected by the creditworthiness of the issuer. Limits of exposure are set by the investment committee and are continuously monitored. Sales of products and services are made to customers with an appropriate credit history. The group has policies in place that limit the credit exposure to any institution and reputable reinsurers are used for the group’s reinsurance treaties.

Currency risk

The operations have limited collective investment schemes invested offshore which is denominated in foreign currencies. The currency risk is not hedged as the investments are mainly made on behalf of shareholders for the purpose of obtaining a desirable international exposure in foreign currencies.

 

6.

 

Significant accounting judgments and estimates

 
  

Long-term insurance operations

Insurance liabilities in respect of long-term insurance contracts and investment contracts

Valuation assumptions represent a best estimate. Compulsory margins are applied as required by the Long-term Insurance Act and discretionary margins may be applied as required by the valuation methodology or if the Statutory Actuary considers such margins necessary to cover the risks inherent in the contracts. The valuation of investment contracts is linked to the fair value of the supporting assets.

Short-term insurance operations

The estimation of the liability arising from claims under short-term insurance contracts is impacted on by several sources of uncertainty. The environment can change unexpectedly and the group is therefore constantly refining its short-term insurance risk management tools in order to assess risk appropriately.

A large proportion of the premium for warranty policies is used to fund up-front costs such as commissions and fees. The remainder of the premium needs to be deferred and recognised as income in line with the expiring risk profile of the policies. These multi-year policies often only become effective once a defined event has occurred, for example, after the motor manufacturers’ warranty has expired.

The company uses a stochastic model to calculate the IBNR at 75% level of sufficiency. The methodology for the allocation of reserves is consistent with Regent’s internal capital allocation model. Reserves are set at the 75th percentile level to be consistent with the proposed Financial Condition Reporting requirements.